August 12th, 2025
The visual signals that separate inbox heroes from spam suspects, according to new data-backed research.
Your SPF and DKIM are airtight. Your list is opt-in. So what else can you do to help hit the inbox that first time?
Turns out, inboxes have bouncers at the door like Berlin's Berghain, quietly turning you away based on how you look.
Even if your setup is pristine and your recipients opted in with eyes wide open, design choices can tip your message from the inbox into the spam box. This isn’t a guide for shady senders trying to game the system. It’s for marketers who’ve done the hard work and still get filtered out because they may be under- or overdressed for the email party.
When everything else is optimized, design becomes your silent hero—or your inbox saboteur.
That’s where the Visual Triage Model comes in: a framework we've been working on for understanding how email design subtly influences those first emails in the inbox. Based on new research from Folderly (which analyzed 10,000+ campaigns for this article), we’ve mapped the visual traits that separate trusted messages from ones that raise red flags.
While at Unspam this year, Mike (RGE’s Co-founder) raised a question:
"Does design impact a sender's reputation, or is it just the text and setup that an inbox cares about?" We had the data. So we went digging.
Yes, SPF, DKIM, and a clean list matter. Let that be the absolute starting point. But here’s what often gets overlooked: Gmail, Outlook, and friends don't just check headers, they evaluate the whole email. They’re using behavioral filters and machine-learning systems trained on millions of user interactions. Design plays a huge role in that judgment.
Google’s own sender guidelines confirm that formatting (especially image-to-text balance and promotional structure) can affect tab placement in Gmail.
Postmark and Mailgun echo this, pointing out that image weight, button-to-text ratios, and layout complexity are all used as quality heuristics, especially when you’re still establishing trust.
We paired Folderly’s campaign-level data with audits across hundreds of Really Good Emails examples to spot what reliably works and what consistently hurts your chances.
What emerged is a set of visual signals that inbox providers are picking up on, whether you realize it or not. Enter the Visual Triage Model.
Think of inbox placement like a security checkpoint:
INBOX: clean, structured, human
Traits that whisper, "this is someone you know":
Design TL;DR: Look like a human who understands that this is probably the first time they are seeing your message.
PROMOTIONS: polished, branded, clearly marketing
These aren't bad emails, but they often end up in one folder down from where you want to be.
Traits that say, “this is legit, but also trying to sell me something”:
Design TL;DR: Good vibes. Branded vibes. But probably a promo.
SPAM: Deceptive, Cluttered, or Sloppy
Traits that make inbox filters (and users) hit the 🚫:
Design TL;DR: Trying too hard and saying too little.
You’ve seen them on Really Good Emails. You’ve probably sent them. And they’re gorgeous. So why do welcome emails get a pass? Because they’re:
In these cases, inbox placement is helped by trust, aggregated behavior, and timing. If your brand is known, and your infrastructure’s strong, you can go heavier on the visuals. But if you’re new to someone’s inbox, simplicity is still your safest bet.
Design is the handshake but it’s not the whole relationship. You could have the most elegant email in the world (meticulously styled, perfectly branded), but if your backend’s not in shape, it won’t matter. Inbox placement is a team effort.
Filters triangulate across:
Design is what they see, but they're also asking:
No one element works in isolation. Design isn’t a silver bullet—it’s the polish that only works when everything else is aligned.
Back to our club analogy: If SPF is your ticket, design is your outfit. Show up dressed like a trusted friend and you’ll probably get waved through. Show up shouting in neon Comic Sans with a flashing “BUY NOW” badge and you’re not getting past the velvet rope. Design doesn’t just dress your content. It shapes your reputation. Treat it like inbox insurance—because looking trustworthy is the first step to being trusted.
Categories:
Email Design
One year after the acquisition, we’re still weird, still writing newsletters, just with more people. Here’s what we learned.
Six months ago, we sold ReallyGoodEmails.com after a decade of building it from the ground up. Here’s a peek behind the curtain and a rundown of the top 10 things I wish I had known when we first started ReallyGoodEmails. Hopefully, these will save you a few sleepless nights if you're building something similar.
Dive into the world of unmatched copywriting mastery, handpicked articles, and insider tips & tricks that elevate your writing game. Subscribe now for your weekly dose of inspiration and expertise.